The Best Quesadilla Makers

A good quesadilla maker is one of those kitchen gadgets that every foodie should have in their cabinets. There are few things better than a crispy quesadilla dripping in cheese and butter, but here's a little secret: a regular skillet is vastly inferior to a quesadilla maker. That's because, with a quesadilla maker, the process of whipping up your favorite Mexican staple food is easier, quicker, and more streamlined, since that's what this tool is designed to do. Plus, these gadgets are just plain cute. Here, we've rounded up the five best quesadilla makers available, and grouped them by category. (Sorry in advance for making your mouth water.)

Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker

Better than restaurant-quality

There's no need to go out to eat when you have the Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon

Get ready for a foodie fiesta with the Hamilton Beach 25409 Quesadilla Maker, which churns out the tastiest quesadillas imaginable, with minimal effort and super-easy cleanup. Crucially, the lid lock and edge-sealing ring help to keep the food tightly secured. The nonstick surface wipes totally clean; all you have to do is do a quick wipe with a damp cloth, and you’re done. And, in a thoughtful touch, this maker even comes with a booklet of recipes—it’s never been easier to whip up delicious quesadillas than it is with this handy little gadget.

Pros:

  • Tasty quesadillas are ready in just five minutes
  • You get six wedges
  • Locking lid prevents cheesy messes; cleanup is a breeze
  • Nonstick surface wipes clean
  • Comes with recipes

Cons:

  • It only makes quesadillas, so it’s a very dedicated appliance—if you’re looking for something more versatile, this isn’t it

Elite Gourmet Quesadilla Maker

Say goodbye to cheesy messes

Cleanup has never been easier than with the Elite Gourmet Quesadilla Maker.
Easiest Cleanup

Find on Amazon

If you’re the type who hates spending a bunch of time cleaning up after you cook (so: most of us), then the Elite Gourmet Quesadilla Maker is the ideal product. You don’t have to use a harsh cleaner or even soap to get this maker clean—simply wipe the nonstick surface with a cloth, and you’ll be good to go. It stands upright, which allows for neat, organized storage after you’re done cooking, and the cheery red color is just plain adorable. There’s even a drip tray underneath, which catches extra grease, resulting in tasty, healthy quesadillas.

Pros:

  • Really easy cleanup; you just have to wipe it with a cloth
  • Has a spacious 11-inch cooking surface
  • Compact design and neat, organized storage
  • Drainage drip tray catches excess grease
  • Two indicator lights let you know when the unit has power and when it’s preheated
  • Cute red color

Cons:

  • There are no settings; it just cooks on high

Nostalgia 10-Inch Quesadilla Maker

Scrumptious, sizable quesadillas for days

Make the perfectly-sized quesadillas with the Nostalgia 10-Inch Maker.
Best 10-Inch

Find on Amazon

The Nostalgia 10-Inch Quesadilla Maker boasts a unique cooking plate—when the lid closes, the cooking plate creates six evenly-cut wedges, so you don’t have to worry about slicing up the quesadilla yourself. Plus, you can make thin or thick quesadillas depending on your preference, with the two-position latch on the lid. The 10-inch cooking surface is sleek, nonstick, and easy to clean, and the maker itself stands upright so you can neatly store it away when you’re done.

Pros:

  • When the lid closes, the cooking plate creates six perfectly even wedges
  • You can opt to make thin or thick quesadillas, thanks to the two-position latch on the lid
  • Makes really crispy quesadillas
  • Sleek, nonstick cooking surface
  • Compact storage

Cons:

  • The latch is just a tad flimsy

Bella Quesadilla Maker

Sleek, portable, and oh-so-adorable

To free up counter space, get the Bella 8-Inch Quesadilla Maker.
Best Compact Design

Find on Amazon

If you don’t have a ton of extra counter or storage space in your kitchen, the Bella Quesadilla Maker is a great pick. At just under 3 pounds (and measuring 11 x 9.65 x 4.49 inches), this maker is lightweight, compact, and gets the job done like other quesadilla makers twice its size. It’s made with durable materials and even has a built-in drip reservoir, for grease. And, with its pepper-shaped handle and bright red color, it’s a super-cute addition to your kitchen.

Pros:

  • Weighs just under 3 pounds and has a compact design; perfect if you don’t have a lot of extra space
  • Crafted with durable materials
  • Built-in drip reservoir to catch excess oil
  • Stands upright for easy storage

Cons:

  • The latch may pop open slightly from time to time

Victoria Cast Iron Tortilla Press

Heavy-duty and long-lasting

The Victoria 8-Inch Cast Iron will last you a lifetime.
Best Cast Iron

Find on Amazon

The Victoria Cast Iron Tortilla Press is a fantastic device, beloved for its super-sturdy reinforced design and heavy-duty construction. This maker is bound to last you for years, so if you don’t like replacing your kitchen tools often, then this is the device for you. It’s made of cast-iron that was seasoned at high temperatures, with 100 percent non-GMO vegetable oil, so you can rest assured that it’s high-quality. And, you can opt for one of two sizes: a 6.5 inch or 8 inch. Say hello to some of the best-tasting quesadillas you’ve ever had.

Pros:

  • Restaurant-quality cast iron
  • Durable construction and design
  • Will last for years
  • Choose between two sizes
  • User-friendly base and handle
  • In addition to quesadillas, make empanadas, arepas, or any other number of items

Cons:

  • Definitely on the expensive end

Frequently Asked Questions

What features should I look for in a quesadilla maker?

Size, design, durability, and affordability are all key factors to consider. A good quesadilla maker should be able to hold a 10- to 12-inch tortilla, but it shouldn’t be too big (otherwise the cheese will create a mess). Your quesadilla maker should have a secure-fitting locking lid and a non-stick surface, and it should come at an accessible price point.

Can I use my quesadilla maker to make other kinds of food?

Yes, you can use it to make mini-pizzas or crepes, or you could even make dessert quesadillas.