The 5 Best Muffin Pans

The smell of muffins or cupcakes baking can make anyone's mouth water from across the house. The aroma builds up and you can just see and taste the perfectly domed desserts. Muffins are great for breakfast or a snack. Cupcakes are handy for parties or even just snacks for after work and school. How do you get that signature shape, though? You use a muffin pan, of course. Muffin pans allow for faster baking times and easier to handle sized baked goods when compared to regular cakes and pies. Here are our 5 favorite muffin pans so you can get to baking.

Rachael Ray 54075 Yum-O! Nonstick 12-Cup Cupcake and Muffin Tin

Nonstick and Durable

A super durable muffin pan that is nonstick and easy to bake in.

Top Pick

Find on Amazon

If you are on the hunt for a classic muffin pan then you need the Yum-O! Nonstick 12-Cup Cupcake and Muffin Tin from Rachael Ray’s line of bakeware. This muffin pan is awesome. It is super durable and warp-resistant because it is made of heavy steel. The nonstick coating allows your muffins or cupcakes to pop right without breaking and crumbling.

The handles on this muffin pan have silicone grips in addition to being wider than usual. Because of this, you don’t have to worry about dropping your muffins on their way in or out of the oven. Check out these pros and cons so you can decide if the Rachael Ray muffin pan is the right one for you.

Pros:

The nonstick coating works really well
This pan is super easy to maneuver because of the well-designed handles
The heavy-gauge steel will make this pan last for years
It is easy to clean
You can use this pan up to 500 degrees making it perfect for other recipes that call for high heat

Cons:

This pan is more expensive than most
You can only make 12 muffins at a time in this pan

Wilton Perfect Results Premium Nonstick Mega-Sized Muffin Pan

Less Time, More Muffins

The colossal pan that will help you feed your large family or team in less time.

Best for Bulk Baking

Find on Amazon

Wilton is a well-known name in the baking industry. Their Perfect Results Premium Nonstick Mega-Sized Muffin Pan fits in perfectly with their extensive line of baking pans. This Mega-Sized muffin pan makes 24 muffins or cupcakes at a time. It is absolutely perfect for when you have a large family or you bake for large groups of people.

You will feel confident when you bake with this pan. Your muffins will slide right out because of the nonstick coating. In addition, it is super easy to care for. Just throw it in the dishwasher. Here are some pros and cons so you can decide if the Perfect Results Premium muffin pan is right for you.

Pros:

It is extra-large which makes it easy to bake for crowds
This pan is totally nonstick and easy to bake in
It is dishwasher safe
The super-durable construction will allow you to use this pan for years
Handles are large and they make it easier to handle

Cons:

The size makes it a bit hard to wash
It does not fit in smaller convection ovens

Gezan Non-Stick Silicone Muffin Pans

Cute and Affordable

Silicone baking products are nonstick and easy to care for, and it helps that they come in pretty colors.

Top Silicone Set

Find on Amazon

This set of 2 Gezan Non-stick silicone muffin pans is ideal for those looking for an alternative to the bulky metal pans of the past. Silicone is nonstick and easy to care for. Just fill each cup with your muffin batter and let it bake. When they are done you remove them from the oven and pop each one out. There will be no breaking or crumbling while you are trying to get them out of the pan.

These silicone muffin pans are easy to clean and store when you are done using them. You wash them in the dishwasher and then stack them together with the rest of your pots and pans. Let’s take a look at some pros and cons.

Pros:

These are nonstick and allow food to slide right out
They come in cute colors
You get 2 muffin pans for less than you would pay for 1 metal tray
The Gezan muffin pans, in particular, are made to take high temperatures
Food cooks evenly and easily in these pans

Cons:

Silicone can let off a chemical smell at first so you need to wash them and let them air out
They may not last as long as heavy metal baking pans

Suntake Silicone Mini Muffin and Cupcake Pans

Versatile and Bite-Sized

Make the best bite-sized treats for your loved ones.

Best Mini Muffin Pan

Find on Amazon

Do you prefer bite-sized snacks over their larger versions? Maybe you have a big bake sale coming up, and you want to bring something fun and creative for the smaller kids. Either way, the Suntake Silicone Mini Muffin and Cupcake Pans can help. Each pan has 24 mini cups for muffins, cupcakes, or anything else you want to bake. There are 2 pans in each pack, which means you can make 48 mini muffins at a time.

The Suntake Silicone muffin pans can be washed in the dishwasher, used in the microwave or oven, and be frozen. They are durable and free of BPA, lead, phthalates, and PVC. Here are some more pros and cons so you can get an overall look at these muffin pans.

Pros:

They are nonstick and it is easy to get your food out
You can put the batter in the cups and freeze it in these pans so that you can just pop them in the oven when you need them
Use these in the microwave for convenient and fast cooking
Wash them in the dishwasher for easy cleaning
You get 2 pans in the pack

Cons:

Silicone always lets off a chemical odor
They are not as durable as metal pans

USA Pans Nonstick Quick Release Muffin and Cupcake Pan

Made in the USA

The proprietary nonstick coating will make these pans stand out above the rest.

Best Nonstick Coating

Find on Amazon

USA Pans bring you excellent quality bakeware that is nonstick and durable. This is the case with the Nonstick Quick Release Muffin and Cupcake Pan. It is made of strong and durable commercial-grade aluminized steel. The patented Americoat creates an awesome quick-release nonstick surface so you never need to worry about your food getting stuck or your pans being hard to clean.

USA Pan offers a lifetime warranty on all of their products so you can feel confident with your purchase. If your food sticks or it doesn’t work as well as you expect it to, you can return it any time. Check out these pros and cons so you can decide if you want to give these pans a chance.

Pros:

The lifetime warranty makes this a risk-free investment
These are nonstick and food slides right out
The coating used is PTFE, PFOA, and BPA free
You can easily just rinse these pans to clean them
They do not cost as much as some of the bigger brands

Cons:

You cannot wash these in the dishwasher
They only make 12 muffins at a time

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I make in a muffin pan besides muffins?

People use muffin pans for cupcakes, frittatas, mini quiches, and more. They are pretty versatile.

Does material matter?

The material does matter. Heavy metals may last longer and be more durable than silicone, however, silicone is often cheaper and easier to wash and store. You need to decide what is important for you to decide what type of pan to buy.

Why should I care about whether or not a pan is nonstick?

If a pan is nonstick the food will slide out easier. This means that you are less likely to burn your food or break it trying to get it out of the pan. However, some people prefer pans that do not have any coating at all.