The Best Cookie Cutters

Are you looking for a fun way to spend time with your kids? Get out the cookie cutters and whip up a batch of sugar cookie dough. They'll have a blast trying their hand at rolling out the dough. Then, you can all work together to cut out the shapes with the cookie cutters, and once the cookies are baked, everyone will have a good time decorating them. No matter who in your family is doing the baking and decorating, you really do need a nice set of cookie cutters to make it happen. Here are a few of the best options available.

Kspowwin Stainless Steel Cookie Cutters (5-Piece)

Perfect Circles

You can create a clean cut in your dough with these round cookie cutters.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon

It’s simple to make beautiful cookies with these cookie cutters. The stainless steel design is strong enough to easily push through your dough, giving you a clean cut. This means your cookies are less likely to break or tear as you transfer them onto your baking sheets.

You won’t have to worry about the steel cutting into your hands while you’re pushing down, either. Though the construction of each cutter is very sturdy, the top portion features a rolled edge that protects your fingers and keeps you safe. They really are easy to both use and clean up when you’re done.

Pros

  • Made from high-quality stainless steel with fully welded seams, so they’re strong and safe
  • 5 different sizes ranging from 1.7-3.3 inches, giving you options to make several sizes of cookies
  • Versatile, strong enough to be used on pastries, toast, and more
  • They nest inside each other for storage, taking up less room in your drawers

Cons

  • If you handle them roughly, the stainless steel will bend a bit, giving you ovals instead of circles. However, you can gently bend them back if you’re careful.

Homy Feel Mini Geometric Shaped Cookie Cutters

Keep Their Shape

You don't have to worry about these strong stainless steel cookie cutters getting bent out of shape.
Best Mini

Find on Amazon

If you’re, you know, sane, and you like well-made things, you’ll appreciate how sturdy these small cookie cutters are. Each one is made from high-quality stainless steel, so they’re sure to keep their shape. This means your circles are less likely to turn into ovals, so all of your cookies will come out looking great. The bottom portion of each cutter is sharp enough to slice easily through your dough (or anything else you want to cut). Since the top is rolled, you won’t cut your hands when you push down on them.

The set includes a good variety of shapes and sizes. In all, you get 24 cookie cutters. There are eight different shapes, and each shape has three sizes. To help keep all of these cookie cutters from invading your kitchen space, they come in a storage container. You can nest the cookie cutters inside themselves to make them fit nicely inside.

Pros

  • Nice package design where the cookie cutters all fit inside the storage tin, making it a good option to give as a gift
  • No sharp seams on the cookie cutters, so they’re easy to use and clean
  • Good variety, including rectangles, squares, hearts, triangles, ovals, and more so that you can make plenty of pretty cookies, biscuits, or crafts

Cons

  • These are mini cookie cutters. The largest one of each shape is about 1.5 inches, so if you’re expecting larger ones, you’ll be disappointed.

Wilton Cookie Cutters Set

Great Variety

Your kids will have a blast using these cookie cutters for cookies and crafts.
Best for Kids

Find on Amazon

Unless you’re a monster (or perhaps even then, in some cases), you don’t want your kids to get hurt pushing on stainless steel cookie cutters that could be a little sharp. Instead, let them use these plastic ones. They’re safer for kids to try on their own. You can let them use them for shaping cookies, making shaped sandwiches, cutting out play dough, and much more.

This set of 101 cookie cutters includes a complete alphabet. Your kids will have a blast using these to make cookies that spell out their names. In addition to the alphabet, you’ll find shapes for different holidays, numbers, basic shapes, and more. There is so much variety that you’ll find yourself reaching for this collection over and over again.

Pros

  • Kid-friendly design with no sharp edges to get cut on
  • Bright colors and a variety of shapes make these cookie cutters fun to use for you and your kids
  • This is a great price point considering you get over 100 cookie cutters

Cons

  • You’re going to have cookie cutters you don’t like or use, which is to be expected with this much variety. However, even if you only, say, half of them, it’s still a good deal. You’ll just have a lot to store or pass on.

BakingWorld Unicorn Cookie Cutter Set

Rainbows and Unicorns

Bring magical creatures and shapes to life with these fun unicorn-themed cookie cutters.
Best for Fantasy Fans

Find on Amazon

Do you know a young girl who’s obsessed with all things unicorns? Make her day by baking up a batch of unicorn cookies for her to decorate. You’ll get nine different fantasy themed cutters in this set, with several different unicorns and unicorn heads to choose from.

These stainless steel cookie cutters cut cleanly, so you won’t have to worry about the unicorn’s horn falling off when you transfer it. (Can you imagine how sad a unicorn without a horn would be?) The top has a nice rolled metal edge so that you can safely push down without getting hurt. They’re a great addition to any collection of cookie cutters.

Pros

  • Cute shapes that will thrill anyone who likes unicorns
  • Good sizes for cookies – cutters range from 2.36-3.94 inches
  • Made from thick stainless steel that is harder to bend out of shape than the thin stuff

Cons

  • These don’t nest for easy storage, so you’ll need to store them creatively to keep them contained

Ann Clark Cookie Cutters for Every Season

Shapes for Every Season

No matter what time of year it is, you can celebrate the special days with cookies.
Best for Seasonal Use

Find on Amazon

If you only take the time to roll and cut cookies on special occasions, this is the set you need. It’s got 11 different shapes, each representing different holidays and seasons. You’ll be able to find just what you need to make the cookies for your celebration. It’s a great collection that won’t leave a bunch of unused cookie cutters hanging around your kitchen.

Made in the United States, these cookie cutters are constructed with certified food-safe stainless steel. You won’t have to worry about anything toxic touching the cookies you’re going to eat.

Pros

  • A shape for each season or major holiday, so you won’t have to buy a lot of additional cutters
  • Good quality that will last for many baking sessions
  • The sharp edge cuts easily through your dough, giving you a clean cut that makes your cookies look nice

Cons

  • Comes with a pencil shape, which is presumably for back-to-school celebrations. Still, it’s a sort of weird addition to this set

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I only use cookie cutters to cut cookie dough?

No. Most cookie cutters can be used to cut many different things. Depending on the size and thickness of your cutters, you can use them for baking and crafts. They work really well for kids to use to cut play dough. They can also be used as stencils for art projects. If your kids enjoy eating shaped foods, you can use these to cut sandwiches, toast, and more. With a bit of outside the box thinking (or outside the cookie cutter, in this case), you’ll find plenty of ways to use your cookie cutters.

How should I store cookie cutters?

You want to make sure your cookie cutters are completely dry before storing them. This helps to prevent rust from forming. When they’re dry, you can place them in a drawer; however, they tend to shift around and can take up a lot of space when stored loosely this way. To help keep them all contained, you might want to put them in a container. Many people store their cookie cutters in a cookie jar. This looks cute sitting on the counter and helps keep them all together. You can also keep them hung up on a pegboard, in a bin with a lid, or in a different type of storage container. You’ll just have to figure out what works best in your kitchen.