The Top 5 Breakfast Sandwich Makers

Who doesn't love a delicious breakfast sandwich first thing in the morning, with a giant mug of steaming black coffee? Whether you like a fried egg sandwich with cheese, an egg-sausage combo, or a toasted English muffin when you roll out of bed, one thing is clear: It's crucial to have a legit breakfast sandwich maker on hand, to help you get your day started on the right track. After all, how else are you going to prepare all those yummy gourmet sandwiches for you and your loved ones? A breakfast sandwich maker is one of those handy little kitchen appliances that no good cook should be without. Here are our picks for the five best.

Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker

The king of sandwich makers

Everyone's favorite breakfast sandwich maker is simply a must-have kitchen tool.

Best Overall

Find on Amazon

The undisputed creme de la creme of sandwich makers, the Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker is one your one-way ticket to the most delicious (and, not to mention, fastest) breakfast sandwiches of your life. The design is highly efficient—this maker has separate sections for toasting bread and frying eggs, and then putting your sandwich together; the whole process takes just under five minutes. Every single piece of this device is dishwasher-friendly, too, making it a breeze to clean.

Pros:

Takes just five minutes to cook your perfect breakfast (or lunch, or even dinner sandwich).
Super-efficient design; there are separate sections for toasting bread, frying eggs, and putting the sandwich together.
Makes for easy cleanup; all of the removable parts are dishwasher-safe.
Choose between two sizes and colors.

Cons:

On the pricey end.

Cuisinart Dual-Sandwich Nonstick Electric Grill

No more messy clean-up

Thanks to this sandwich maker's supreme nonstick capabilities, you won't have to worry about cleaning up a huge mess in the kitchen.

Best Nonstick Skillet

Find on Amazon

Gotta love a nonstick grill in the mornings—after all, who wants to take a ton of time to cook and prepare a sandwich (and then deal with clean-up) when you’re still bleary-eyed and haven’t had enough coffee? Enter the Cuisinart Dual-Sandwich Nonstick Electric Grill, which boasts superior nonstick capabilities, to ensure minimal prep time and clean-up. This maker also has a lock-down lid and deep-pocket design, so your sandwich cooks evenly on both sides, plus a diagonal indentation that allows you to easily slice your sandwich in two.

Pros:

Excellent nonstick capabilities.
Deep-pocket design that can cook one or two sandwiches at once.
Lock-down lid ensures that each sides cooks evenly.
Seals with a diagonal indentation, so you can easily slice your sandwich in half.
Red and green indicator lights, so you can keep track of when your food is ready.

Cons:

It’s a bit tricky to close.

OSTBA Sandwich Maker

Hi-tech design for the win

Efficiency is key in a good sandwich maker, and this one pretty much oozes efficiency at every turn.

Best Technology

Find on Amazon

Talk about hi-tech—the OSTBA Sandwich Maker was built to make the tastiest, most efficient breakfast sandwiches, with every aspect of its design. Sleek and compact, this maker has 750 watts of high power, a cool-touch locking handle (for safe operation), nonstick grill plates, and indicator lights, all of which make the sandwich-making process as painless as possible. And, conveniently, the brand offers a two-year quality warranty.

Pros:

Nonstick grill plates = quick and easy clean-up.
Compact, sleek design that makes for efficient storage.
Cooks sandwiches fast and evenly.
Cool-touch locking handle.
Comes with a two-year quality warranty.

Cons:

There’s no timer.

Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker

Double the fun (and the deliciousness)

Why make one delectable breakfast sandwich when you could make two?

Best Double Sandwich Maker

Find on Amazon

If you regularly make multiple breakfast sandwiches, then the Gotham Steel Sandwich Maker is bound to become your new kitchen BFF. This nifty little device allows you to make two sandwiches at once (it evenly toasts four slices of bread in one go), and, thanks to the ultra-nonstick cooking surface, you don’t even need to use butter or oil when you cook. Clean-up is swift, too, which is always a plus.

Pros:

You can easily make two sandwiches at once: This device makes four evenly toasted slices of bread in less than five minutes.
Has an ultra-nonstick cooking surface that’s reinforced with titanium and ceramic; no oil or butter needed.
Portable and compact.
Seals with a diagonal indentation for easy slicing.

Cons:

It would be nice if the bread got a tad crispier.

CJSWT Electric Sandwich Maker

Oh-so-chic, oh-so-functional

Seriously, is there anything this sandwich maker can't do?

Best Multi-Functional

Find on Amazon

The CJSWT Electric Sandwich Maker pretty much has it all—intelligent temperature control, a clear indicator light, a compact size, and supreme nonstick coating. Best of all, this multi-functional appliance allows you cook a variety of breakfast foods, including waffles and panini—the detachable plates include a sandwich maker, panini press, and waffle iron. All that, and the pink color is just plain chic.

Pros:

Multi-functional; you can cook a variety of breakfast foods ranging from sandwiches to waffles to panini.
Intelligent temperature control: If the temp gets too high, this device shuts off automatically.
Small, compact size that doesn’t take up too much space in the cupboard.
Adorable pink color.

Cons:

Very pricey.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a breakfast sandwich maker and a toaster?

While a toaster is for toasting bread only, a breakfast sandwich maker allows you to custom-make your own sandwiches (using eggs, bread, cheese, or whatever else you like) and then place them inside the device—resulting in a hot, hearty, delicious breakfast, whenever you want.

Why should I buy a breakfast sandwich maker instead of buying the sandwiches themselves?

Two important reasons: You’ll save money, and you’ll also get to customize your sandwiches using all your fave ingredients. Not to mention, if you regularly have people over, love making meals for the fam on the weekends, or are planning a big home-cooked brunch, having a breakfast sandwich maker on hand is super-convenient.